This is the Most Popular Cheese in America WHUR Contributor March 15, 2021 at 10:00 am in LIFESTYLE Tweet A new survey says that Americans’ favorite cheese is…CHEDDAR! The survey conducted by YouGov asked voters to choose their favorite cheeses from a list of 16. Cheddar took 19% of the vote, followed by American with 13%, mozzarella, Swiss, and Pepper Jack. Most surprising result for this data? 4% of Americans voting didn’t even LIKE cheese. What is your favorite cheese? What type of cheese do you not like? How do you eat cheese?